Quick Columbus OH MLS Search

Browse All Columbus OH Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

$449,900
4 Beds 4 Baths Michael Mundey
Welcome to 340 S. Kellner Road, where exceptional space, a versatile floor plan, and an unbeatable location come together in one of Eastmoor's most desirable neighborhoods. Offering over 3,200 square feet of finished living space, this spacious ranch sits on a quiet, tree-lined street just minutes from Bexley, Downtown Columbus, the airport, shopping, dining, parks, and major highways. The thoughtfully designed layout features four spacious bedrooms and three full bathrooms on the main level, including a private primary suite tucked away at the rear of the home with its own full bath, creating a peaceful retreat separate from the rest of the home. Three additional generously sized bedrooms are complemented by two full hallway bathrooms, providing exceptional flexibility for family, guests, or multigenerational living. The oversized kitchen offers abundant cabinetry, generous workspace, stainless steel appliances, and an adjoining eating area, while multiple living and gathering spaces make entertaining easy. Cozy up around one of two wood-burning fireplaces, located on both the main level and in the expansive finished lower level. The finished lower level provides an enormous recreation room, additional flex space for a home office, fitness area, hobby room, media room, or play area, plus the convenience of a half bath. Outdoor living is equally impressive with both an enclosed porch and a huge screened three-season room overlooking the private fenced backyard, creating the perfect setting for relaxing or entertaining throughout much of the year. Lovingly maintained by the same owners for many years, this home offers an exceptional combination of space, functionality, and location. Homes with this amount of living space, flexible layout, and prime Eastmoor location rarely become available. Don't miss this incredible opportunity!

340 S Kellner Road, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Michael Mundey ---- EXP Realty, LLC

$499,900
Oliver Chapman
First time offered for sale in over 40 years! This well-maintained Clintonville duplex presents an exceptional investment opportunity in one of Columbus' most sought-after neighborhoods. Whether you're looking to house hack, expand your rental portfolio, or capitalize on the area's strong student and professional rental demand, this property checks all the boxes. Each side features 3 spacious bedrooms, 1 full bath, updated kitchens and bathrooms, beautiful hardwood floors, decorative fireplaces, and original woodwork that showcases the home's timeless 1920s character. Covered front porches provide the perfect place to relax, while the second-floor hardwood floors and charming architectural details add warmth and appeal throughout. The property has been thoughtfully maintained with updated electric panels, sub-metered water, and separate full dry basements with laundry hookups for each unit. Outside, tenants will appreciate three off-street parking spaces, a rear fire pit gathering area, and low-maintenance outdoor living. Located on a quiet street in the heart of Clintonville, residents enjoy easy access to High Street's popular restaurants, coffee shops, breweries, and local businesses, while remaining just minutes from The Ohio State University, the Olentangy Trail, Whetstone Park of Roses, and major commuter routes. This classic duplex offers the rare combination of character, location, and long-term investment potential. 181-183 Olentangy Street is a rare opportunity to own a fully functional duplex in a neighborhood where demand remains consistently strong.

181 Olentangy Street, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Oliver Chapman ---- Keller Williams Consultants

$444,900
2 Beds 2 Baths Kelsey Jones
Nestled in the heart of Merion Village, just a few blocks from Schiller Park and everything German Village has to offer, this charming cape cod cottage blends timeless character with modern convenience. Warm wood floors, original details, and abundant natural light create an inviting atmosphere throughout. The updated kitchen features quartz countertops, ample cabinet space, and a layout that flows seamlessly into the main living areas, making it ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. A dedicated first-floor office offers flexibility for working from home or additional living space, while a full bath adds convenience on the main level. Upstairs, a private retreat is arranged as a cozy bedroom, creating a welcoming and comfortable space. The finished lower level offers additional living space and is currently used as a bedroom, providing versatility for guests, hobbies, recreation, or a home office. Even with the finished lower level, the basement still provides valuable storage space and a dedicated laundry area. Outside, the large yard is a rare find in German Village, offering room to relax, garden, or entertain. A detached one-car garage adds convenience and extra storage, while the attached overhang features built-in cabinets and offers a versatile covered space for outdoor entertaining, dining, or relaxing. Located within walking distance of neighborhood restaurants, coffee shops, and local favorites, this cozy cottage is a wonderful opportunity to enjoy one of Columbus' most sought-after historic communities.

373 Stewart Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Kelsey Jones ---- RE/MAX Partners

$500,000
3 Beds 2 Baths Joshua L Dawson
Some homes are just a place to sleep. This isn't one of them. 590 W. 2nd Avenue is a renovated 1900 three-bedroom, 1.5-bath home in Columbus's Harrison West neighborhood, next to Harrison Park and the Olentangy Trail, with 1,873 square feet across three full levels and a city outside the front door worth actually living in. A covered front porch opens into a main level with tall ceilings and an open-concept kitchen with white cabinetry, a granite island, a stainless French-door refrigerator, subway tile backsplash, and open shelving. The kitchen flows into a sizable dining area and a spacious living room built for entertaining, while a 2018 addition added a second living area with a fireplace. New flooring and fresh paint run throughout the main level. Upstairs, three nicely sized bedrooms including the primary share a remodeled full bath with a granite vanity, exposed brick accent, and a tiled tub-shower. A finished third-floor loft with vaulted ceilings adds flex space for a home office or studio. A full, unfinished basement provides additional storage and a second laundry setup. Outside, a fenced backyard leaves room for a garden, with a paver patio, a Trex deck, and a cedar pergola for outdoor living. A detached three-car garage plus an additional off-street parking spot bring four total parking spaces, convenient to downtown Columbus. From here, Goodale Park, the Short North Arts District, and the Scioto Mile are all close by, with Victorian Village just next door and Nationwide Arena, Lower.com Field, and Huntington Park within reach for Blue Jackets, Crew, and Clippers games. The Ohio State University campus and Wexner Medical Center sit along the same river corridor, with Grant Medical Center and downtown's other hospitals also within easy reach. At 590 W. 2nd Avenue, ownership in Harrison West comes with the park, the river, and the city itself, right outside the front door.

590 W 2nd Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Joshua L Dawson ---- Josh Dawson Real Estate, LLC

$458,000
4 Beds 3 Baths Annette R Fleming
Nestled in the desirable Sycamore Hills neighborhood, this versatile 2,394-square-foot home is situated on one of the community's larger ravine lots, offering a peaceful setting complete with a picturesque stream and incredible privacy. Inside, you'll find a spacious and functional floor plan designed for everyday living with gorgeous wood floors thoughout. Generously sized formal living and dining rooms flow into the kitchen and connect seamlessly to the main living area, creating an inviting space for gathering with family and friends. The first-floor laundry room has abundant storage with practical workspace to simplify your daily routine. Upstairs, you'll find four generously sized bedrooms, each offering ample closet space. The primary suite serves as a comfortable retreat, featuring a beautifully updated en-suite bath, abundant closet space, and charming touches that make it feel like home. This home has a fun nook hideway in a spare bedroom for kids adventures. The outdoor deck and patio offer the perfect backdrop for entertaining or simply relaxing in your own private retreat. The walkout lower level offers an additional 1332 sf ft with endless possibilities of unfinished space ready for your personal vision--whether it's a recreation room, home gym, home office, or additional living area. The gently sloping backyard even transforms into the perfect sledding hill during the winter months. If you've been searching for a home that combines space, privacy, and a truly spectacular setting, this Sycamore Hills gem is one you won't want to miss!

1332 Brookridge Drive, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Annette R Fleming ---- RE/MAX Revealty

$409,000
3 Beds 1 Baths Jeffery W Ruff
Welcome to this beautifully maintained Merion Village home, where timeless character meets thoughtful updates. Freshly painted and move-in ready, this 3-bedroom home welcomes you with a brand new front door and an inviting front porch perfect for morning coffee and evening conversations. Inside, newly refinished hardwood floors add charm to the living and dining rooms. A gas log fireplace completes the living room. The spacious kitchen offers plenty of counter space and a charming eat-in dining space. Upstairs, three bedrooms offer the flexibility for a home office or walk-in closet. The recently renovated full bath adds modern convenience. The full basement provides excellent storage and flexibility. Other recent improvements include a new furnace (2025), newer air conditioner (2025), a new washer and dryer (2025), and a newer hot water tank (2023). Outside, you'll find a fenced backyard with a private concrete patio and pergola--an ideal setting for summer dinners, entertaining friends, or simply unwinding at the end of the day. The 2-car garage is conveniently accessed from the alley. Located just minutes from German Village and within close proximity to neighborhood parks, local restaurants, coffee shops, and favorite pubs, this home offers the perfect blend of historic charm, modern updates, and a true village lifestyle. See A2A remarks.

177 Frebis Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Jeffery W Ruff ---- Cutler Real Estate

$460,000
Gregory S Kullman
An exceptional opportunity in the heart of Olde Towne East, this beautifully updated brick duplex offers timeless architectural character paired with modern convenience. Each residence features three bedrooms, one full and one half bath, spacious living and dining areas, and thoughtfully renovated interiors designed for today's lifestyle. Historic details including exposed brick accents, decorative fireplaces, oversized windows, and soaring ceilings are complemented by updated kitchens, refreshed baths, and contemporary finishes throughout. Expansive third-floor spaces provide flexibility for additional living, work-from-home, or guest accommodations, while unfinished basements offer abundant storage. A welcoming covered front porch overlooks one of Columbus' most sought-after urban neighborhoods, known for its historic charm, tree-lined streets, and vibrant sense of community. The generous rear yard and four off-street parking spaces, two dedicated to each residence, add convenience rarely found in the urban core. Ideally situated just minutes from Downtown Columbus, Franklin Park Conservatory, Nationwide Children's Hospital, and John Glenn Columbus International Airport, this property offers exceptional accessibility to the city's premier employment, dining, entertainment, and cultural destinations. Whether seeking a compelling investment opportunity, house-hacking potential, or a distinctive multi-family property in one of Columbus' most dynamic neighborhoods, this Olde Towne East duplex presents a rare combination of character, location, and versatility.

31-33 Linwood Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Gregory S Kullman ---- Street Sotheby's International

$459,000
3 Beds 2 Baths Annette R Marble
Stunning Italianate-style ranch home custom built by Gallucci Brothers Custom Builders and loaded with quality updates, timeless character, and thoughtful details throughout! Nestled on a quiet street with a nearby walking path, this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers the perfect blend of elegance and comfort. Step inside and you'll immediately appreciate the soaring ceilings, freshly painted walls and trim, custom blinds, and beautiful built-in nooks and features that add charm and functionality throughout the home. The spacious great room showcases gorgeous hardwood flooring and a stunning masonry gas fireplace that creates a warm and inviting focal point. The home offers both a formal dining room and an additional dining area off the kitchen, giving you plenty of space for entertaining and everyday living. One of the standout features is the impressive 16x17 four-season Sunroom complete with its own mini-split heating source, making it the perfect place to relax year-round. The spacious primary suite includes a private sitting area along with a luxurious primary bath featuring a soaking tub, your own personal retreat at the end of the day. Downstairs, the huge full basement with 8-foot ceilings provides endless possibilities for future living space and already includes a rough-in for a full bath. Major mechanical updates have already been completed within the last four years including the roof, HVAC system, and sump pump, offering peace of mind for the new owner. Additional updates include new screens for all windows. Outside, enjoy the patio, storage shed, and oversized 2-car garage. This exceptional custom home delivers quality craftsmanship, modern updates, and a fantastic location all in one package.

5954 Rainwater Way, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Annette R Marble ---- Key Realty

Start Your Search

Between $400K - $500K Columbus Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Columbus and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!