Quick Columbus OH MLS Search

Browse All Columbus OH Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

$419,900
3 Beds 2 Baths Teresa M Kenney
When they say convenient to everything, 319 E Gates St is pretty much what they mean. Morning coffee in Merion Village. Dinner in German Village. A quick run downtown. Work at Nationwide Children's Hospital without building your whole day around the commute. And with easy access to I-70, I-71, I-670 and the airport, getting just about anywhere in Columbus is refreshingly simple. Then you come home to this charming 3-bedroom home on a brick street, with a manicured front lawn, a fantastic covered front porch and the kind of character that only gets better with time. Inside, dark hardwood floors, wide white trim and large windows give the home warmth and personality, while tons of natural light keep everything feeling bright and fresh. The white kitchen is crisp and cheerful, the bedrooms are surprisingly spacious, and thoughtful updates throughout add comfort without losing the historic charm that makes the house so appealing. Out back, the fully fenced yard gives you room to garden, entertain, let the dog run or simply enjoy a little privacy. The large deck is ready for warm-weather dinners and weekend get-togethers, and the oversized 2-car garage is one of those features you appreciate more and more once you have it. And then there's that front porch. Coffee in the morning. A glass of wine at the end of the day. A front-row seat to one of Merion Village's charming brick streets. Open Sunday 9/13 from 1- 3.

319 E Gates Street, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Teresa M Kenney ---- Keller Williams Consultants

$479,900
4 Beds 3 Baths Morgan A Chalcraft
Finally, the one you have been waiting for! One word to describe 1114 E Rich Street: idyllic. Set on a charming street in the heart of Olde Towne East, this elevated and chic 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers nearly 2,300 square feet of character-filled living space and all the warmth you hope to find in a historic home. Beautifully refinished original wide-plank hardwood floors, custom inside-mount shutters, statement built-ins and thoughtful details carry throughout, while smart updates make everyday living easy. The renovated mudroom with dedicated coat and shoe storage, Elfa custom primary closet system, newer 2.5-car garage, and Trex front porch are just a few of the improvements that set this home apart. Out back, the fully fenced yard feels like its own retreat, complete with professional Oakland landscaping and a paver patio with gas firepit, an ideal setting for hosting family and friends. Minutes from Downtown Columbus, East Market, Franklin Park Conservatory and Nationwide Children's Hospital, with easy access to everything that makes Olde Towne East such a special place to call home. The property is tax abated through 2027, with the first full tax bill not due until 2029. Filled with natural light and personality, 1114 E Rich is the kind of home that feels special the moment you walk through the door. New roof in 2018, 2.5- car garage was built in 2021. For a full list of updates see the Documents tab. Open House Saturday, September 19 1-3pm.

1114 E Rich Street, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Morgan A Chalcraft ---- RE/MAX Revealty

$499,900
4 Beds 3 Baths Katie C Winslow
Welcome to this beautifully renovated, spacious two-story traditional home situated on a manicured corner lot in highly sought-after Knolls West, across from Upper Arlington while benefiting from Columbus taxes. Thoughtfully updated with modern finishes, inside and out, this turnkey residence offers the perfect blend of luxury, comfort and convenience. Featuring 4 spacious bedrooms, 2.5 fully updated baths, a 2-car garage, this home is designed to impress from the moment you arrive. The charming front porch, manicured landscaping, extended driveway with additional off-street parking, a quarter-acre lot create standout curb appeal and outdoor space. The fully fenced private backyard offers large green space along with a paver brick patio, enjoying quiet evenings at home and offering a piece of mind for pets. Inside, the first floor has been completely reimagined with an open-concept design, beautiful new flooring, black doors with brass hardware, new light fixtures, accent walls create warm, inviting living spaces. The stunning kitchen serves as the centerpiece of the home, featuring expanded custom cabinetry, granite countertops, eat-in penninsula, pantry, new appliances. The kitchen flows seamlessly into the dining and living areas, where a brick fireplace adds warmth. Upstairs, refinished hardwood floors lead to four generously sized bedrooms, including a spacious primary suite with a walk-in closet and a beautifully updated en-suite bath complete with double vanity, marble tile, and a walk-in shower with seamless glass enclosure. The additional full and half baths have also been thoughtfully renovated with new vanities, led lighted mirrors, custom tile, and fixtures. Abundant closet and storage space. Updated rec room offers apprx. 300 square feet, ideal for a home office-or gym, recreation room, media. Roof 2023, HV/AC 2016, Rosatti Windows 2021. Turn key, quick possession.

1701 Moreland Drive, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Katie C Winslow ---- e-Merge Real Estate

$425,000
3 Beds 2 Baths Isabelle Debra Trepkoski
OPEN HOUSE 9/12 and 9/13 Lovingly renovated and truly move-in ready, this charming home sits on one of Beechwold's most sought-after streets, beautifully blending its original character with thoughtful modern updates. Stunning hardwood floors run throughout the first and second floors, preserving the warmth and character of the home. The kitchen was completely remodeled in 2024, creating a fresh and inviting space to cook and gather, while the light-filled sunroom/den offers a beautiful setting for dining, relaxing, or entertaining. With a new HVAC system and NEW ROOF, many of the major updates have already been taken care of. Upstairs features three bedrooms with hardwood floors, a full bathroom, generous closet space, and charming original built-ins. The full basement adds even more functionality with a second full bathroom, laundry area, plenty of storage, and great potential to finish the space for additional living or recreation space. Outside, enjoy a 1.5-car garage and covered patio overlooking the backyard. Less than two miles from the Park of Roses and just down the street from many of Clintonville's favorite restaurants and local spots, this home offers the character of an established neighborhood with the comfort and convenience of modern updates. All that's left to do is move in and enjoy. Special financing available to help create a lower initial monthly payment with a Temporary Buy-Down. Flexible buyer-focused terms available. Ask your agent for details on promotional financing options available for this home.

143 E Weisheimer Road, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Isabelle Debra Trepkoski ---- Styer RE Professionals

$400,000
3 Beds 3 Baths William J Ruffner
Most century homes in Olde Towne East hand you one or the other: the original woodwork, or a kitchen somebody actually finished. This one kept both. Past the covered front porch, the main level runs open front to back. An exposed brick chimney anchors the living room with built-in floating shelving on either side, and the sightline carries straight through to the dining room under a globe chandelier. Deep navy walls, crown molding room to room, recessed lighting and hardwood throughout. The original staircase, newel post and railing are all still here. The kitchen is two-tone with brass hardware, hex tile backsplash, stone counters and stainless appliances. Just off it, a built-in coffee bar with a living plant wall and a mini bar with both a beverage refrigerator and a wine refrigerator. Morning and evening, covered. A half bath was added on the first floor in 2018. Upstairs the owner's suite is genuinely large, and both full bathrooms are on this floor along with the laundry, which almost nothing built in 1918 can say. The third floor is finished and conditioned by a ductless mini split added in 2023, so it works year round as an office, studio or guest space. At 2,128 square feet across three finished levels there is more house here than the footprint suggests, and the lot is small enough that your weekends stay yours. The mechanical work was done in 2017: Goodman furnace, air conditioning, water heater, electrical panel and shingle roof. Vinyl siding and vinyl windows. The basement is unfinished, with a toilet in place and plumbing rough-in should a future half bath appeal to you. Location carries the rest. Oak Street restaurants and bars are a walk. East Market at the Historic Trolley District, Franklin Park and the Conservatory sit minutes away. Downtown is roughly five minutes, with I-70 and I-71 both close. Homes on this block move on character. This one has it on purpose, not by accident. Schedule your showing.

460 Linwood Avenue, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : William J Ruffner ---- Red 1 Realty

$489,000
4 Beds 3 Baths Melissa J Schwieterman
Westerville Schools! This home offers an Interest Rate Reduction of 1% for the 1st Year! This traditional 2 story home of over 2200 square feet of living space. The main level features a dedicated home office, dining room, living room, family room with fireplace, eat-in area, convenient drop zone with built-in lockers, and a half bath. The open concept kitchen offers an abundance of cabinetry, a center island, and a large pantry. All appliances are included, with a new refrigerator and dishwasher in 2026. Upstairs you'll find four bedrooms and two full bathrooms, including a generously sized primary suite with a spacious private bath and walk-in closet. The partially finished basement adds valuable flex space which is perfect for a rec room, home office, playroom, workout area, or additional sleeping space. The unfinished portion provides plenty of storage along with the laundry area, equipped for either a gas or electric dryer. One of the home's standout features is the enclosed three season room, complete with invisible screens, a ceiling fan, and a beautiful wood ceiling. Step from there onto the deck overlooking the generously sized backyard with mature trees and a firepit this is a wonderful setting for relaxing, entertaining, or enjoying time outdoors. Additional updates include a new A/C unit in 2026 and a humidifier added to the furnace in 2026. With abundant living space, flexible rooms, great outdoor areas, and Westerville Schools, this home has so much to offer!

4224 Eagle Head Drive, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Melissa J Schwieterman ---- Red 1 Realty

$449,900
3 Beds 4 Baths Megan Ann Brown
Built in 2021 and ideally located in the heart of Columbus, this stylish 3-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom condo offers the perfect combination of modern living and an unbeatable urban location. Enjoy close proximity to the Short North and Italian Village, with convenient access to The Ohio State University campus and two major hospitals. Inside, you'll find an open and inviting layout featuring LVP flooring, plush carpeting, and a beautiful kitchen designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen includes a large island, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a convenient beverage refrigerator. The adjoining family room features an electric fireplace, creating a comfortable and welcoming space to relax. With every bedroom offering its own en suite bathroom, this home provides exceptional privacy and flexibility. The entry-level third bedroom is the perfect flex space and can easily serve as a guest suite, home office, or additional living space. Upstairs, the primary suite includes a spacious walk-in closet, while the conveniently located second-floor laundry adds to the home's thoughtful design. Enjoy outdoor living with both a private patio and second-floor balcony, providing multiple spaces to unwind and enjoy the outdoors. An attached two-car garage offers the convenience of private parking and additional storage. Experience all the energy and convenience of city living while enjoying the feel of a private community. Even better, this home benefits from a tax abatement through 2034, creating an incredible opportunity to enjoy newer construction in one of Columbus's most convenient locations.

1239 Cromartie Lane X Unit X, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Megan Ann Brown ---- Engel & Volkers Real Estate Advisors

$484,900
5 Beds 4 Baths Amanda Sheets
Some homes simply have good bones. Others have a soul. 711 Olde Orchard has both. There is something special about the way this 4 to 5 bedroom home with 3.5 baths feels as you enter: warm, collected, and inviting. You can't miss all of the thoughtfully considered details! Custom beadboard, shiplap, built ins, and beautiful wood details give each room a sense of character, while intentional updates make the home feel comfortable and timeless. The spaces unfold naturally, offering a little bit of everything: a front living room that opens toward the dining room, a cozy family room centered around a brick fireplace, a spacious great room, and a sunroom made for lingering a little longer. The kitchen feels equally timeless, with warm wood, painted cabinetry, cherry butcher block counters, and a deep green tile backsplash. Downstairs, the finished basement adds another layer of space with a recreation area, bedroom, full bath, laundry, custom storage, and built ins. And then you walk outside. The covered front porch, back deck, mature and newly added landscaping, fenced yard, and charming storage spaces create a natural extension of the home, with places to sit, gather, slow down, and enjoy the seasons. Behind the beauty is the reassurance of extensive updates, including a new water heater, radon mitigation system, new insulation and drywall in key areas, and refreshed electrical and plumbing. It is a home where the details invite you to look closer, the rooms give you reasons to stay, and the updates let you simply relax and enjoy. Vintage at heart. Thoughtfully renewed. Ready for its next chapter. Ask for the extensive list of renovations and schedule your showing today.

711 Olde Orchard Court, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Amanda Sheets ---- Key Realty

$469,900
3 Beds 4 Baths David M Meyer
Modern Luxury Meets Effortless City Living! Built in 2021, this gorgeous three-story condo townhome offers the perfect blend of sophisticated design, exceptional functionality, and an unbeatable location. Featuring 3 bedrooms, each with its own ensuite bathroom, plus a convenient half bath, this thoughtfully designed home offers plenty of space and privacy. Open-concept kitchen, dining, and living area with beautiful designer updates throughout. The gourmet chef's kitchen is the heart of the home, featuring elevated finishes, generous cabinetry, large island, nook bar and a walk-in pantry. The spacious living area is anchored by a cozy fireplace and opens to a covered porch balcony, creating the perfect spot for morning coffee or evening relaxation. Upstairs you'll find a dream primary suite with two walk in closets and large ensuite bathroom. A second third floor bedroom has a great walk in closet as well as ensuite full bath. Third-floor laundry adds everyday convenience. Storage is abundant throughout the home, making it as practical as it is stylish. Outdoor patio space is perfect for hosting with ample space for gardening, relaxing, grilling and/or outdoor dining. An attached two-car garage provides secure parking and even more storage. Enjoy the benefits of a tax abatement through 2036, adding exceptional value to this already impressive property. Ideally located just minutes from the Short North, The Ohio State University, dining, shopping, entertainment, and everything urban Columbus has to offer. Beautifully maintained, thoughtfully updated, and truly move-in ready--this is city living at its finest.

1231 Cromartie Lane Y Unit Y, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : David M Meyer ---- Sorrell & Company, Inc.

$499,900
4 Beds 3 Baths JP Faulkner
Showings start September 10th, Welcome to 1134 Summerhill, offering the popular M/I Glendale floor plan w/approx. 2,300 sq. ft. on the 1st & 2nd floors, plus an extensively finished LL. This beautifully maintained home retains much of its original character & detail while reflecting exceptional pride of ownership throughout. The main level features a formal LR & DR, a spacious kitchen w/adjacent breakfast room, and a dramatic sunken family room w/cathedral ceiling just off the kitchen. The family room opens to a rear deck overlooking an incredibly landscaped, fully fenced backyard. Mature landscaping has been thoughtfully designed to provide remarkable privacy from nearly every room, highlighted by a stunning approx. 20-ft. magnolia tree. Upstairs are 2 generously sized BRs plus a huge primary suite featuring a 4-piece en suite bath & walk-in closet. The 4th BR is exceptionally spacious and large enough to function as a bonus room, 2nd family room, home office or flexible living space. The finished LL adds even more versatility w/multiple finished rooms, including a large rec room, separate private office and yet another finished room ideal as an additional BR, craft room, hobby space or home gym. The attached garage is equally impressive w/an epoxy floor and built-in storage units. The property has been impeccably maintained, including a newer high-end impact-resistant roof designed to provide enhanced protection against hail. With its spacious and flexible floor plan, beautiful landscaping, exceptional backyard privacy and evident care throughout, 1134 Summerhill offers a rare combination of space, character, comfort and pride of ownership.

1134 Summer Hill Circle, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : JP Faulkner ---- Faulkner Realty Group

$479,900
4 Beds 4 Baths Tonda S Busch
Fully renovated and courtyard-facing, this exceptional brownstone residence is within the iconic Broad-Brunson Place Condominiums, built in 1926 and listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Offering more than 2,600 square feet across four finished levels, this rare 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath home seamlessly blends historic charm with modern luxury. Extensively updated from top to bottom, the home features a gorgeous kitchen with an expansive quartz island, an ASKO dishwasher, and a GE gas range with a center griddle. A separate Butler's Pantry includes a commercial-grade ice maker, a wine and beverage refrigerator, a sink, a built-in wine rack, and a coffee bar that opens to a private covered porch and fenced patio, creating an ideal space for entertaining. The expansive owner's suite showcases a crystal chandelier, a large walk-in closet with generous shelving, and additional his-and-hers closets. A private office with built-in cabinetry and access to a newly rebuilt second-floor balcony provides the perfect work-from-home retreat. Additional highlights include a rare second-floor laundry, custom crown molding, Art Deco-inspired details, decorative fireplaces, Chihuly-inspired lighting, glass-shelved built-ins, and generous storage throughout. The finished lower level offers a spacious recreation room, a full bath, a second laundry area, and private walkout access to a secure, gated garden courtyard that leads to a detached one-car garage. The third floor includes two additional bedrooms, a full bath, and a dedicated heat pump for independent climate control. Designed by renowned architect Robert Hanford, celebrated for his French and Spanish-inspired architecture, Broad-Brunson Place is one of Columbus' most distinctive historic communities--ideally situated just steps from Franklin Park Conservatory and Botanical Gardens and the East Market--minutes from Downtown Columbus, Bexley, and the Short North. Open House Sunday 8/30, 2- 4 p.m

16 Brunson Avenue 6 Unit 6, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Tonda S Busch ---- Key Realty

$473,900
4 Beds 3 Baths Benjamin A Jones
Thoughtfully updated and ready for its next chapter, this spacious Gahanna home blends fresh finishes and major system improvements with the character of an established neighborhood. The main level offers room to spread out with a dedicated office, formal living and dining rooms, first-floor laundry, and a family room featuring a custom fireplace and mantel beneath elevated ceilings. The updated kitchen includes quartz countertops, tile backsplash, stainless steel appliances, new fixtures and refreshed cabinet hardware. Upstairs, the primary suite features a beautifully updated bath with a custom glass-tile shower and quartz countertops, while the additional bathrooms have also been refreshed. Throughout the home, fresh paint, new trim and interior doors, updated hardware and lighting, new LVP flooring and carpet create a clean, cohesive feel. Additional improvements include a brand-new furnace and A/C, new sliding patio door, garage door opener, updated electrical devices, faucets, fixtures and exterior lighting. Outside, fresh landscaping and newly painted exterior trim, brick, garage and entry doors complete the updates. The fully fenced backyard offers plenty of space to enjoy or personalize. Located directly across from Gahanna Middle School South and within Gahanna-Jefferson Schools, with convenient access to shopping, dining and major roadways. Seller is willing to consider an allowance toward window replacement with an acceptable offer, depending on the overall terms.

380 Shady Spring Drive, Columbus

Listing Courtesy of : Benjamin A Jones ---- Keller Williams Greater Cols

Start Your Search

Between $400K - $500K Columbus Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Columbus and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!