New Albany OH 5 Bedroom Real Estate, Homes, Condos for Sale

WOW! EXCEPTIONAL QUALITY, STUNNING UPDATES & AN UNBEATABLE WOODED SETTING! NESTLED ON A PRIVATE, WOODED LOT BACKING TO MATURE TREES IN THE HIGHLY DESIRABLE WOODS AT THE PRESERVE, THIS EXCEPTIONAL M/I BURTON FLOOR PLAN FEATURES 5 BEDROOMS, 3.5 BATHS, AND NEARLY 3,500 SQUARE FEET OF BEAUTIFULLY FINISHED LIVING SPACE ACROSS THREE LEVELS, INCLUDING A FINISHED LOWER LEVEL. ENJOY THE BENEFIT OF NEW ALBANY SCHOOLS WITH COLUMBUS TAXES! RICH CHERRY HARDWOOD FLOORING EXTENDS THROUGH THE ENTRY, DINING ROOM, AND PRIVATE HOME OFFICE. THE SPACIOUS FAMILY ROOM FEATURES BAMBOO HARDWOOD FLOORING, A WOOD-BURNING FIREPLACE WITH A GAS STARTER, DESIGNER TILE SURROUND, AND A DRAMATIC FLOOR-TO-CEILING BOARD AND BATTEN ACCENT WALL. THE ADJOINING FOUR-SEASON SUNROOM OVERLOOKS THE PEACEFUL WOODED BACKYARD. THE MAIN-LEVEL DEN OFFERS CUSTOM BUILT-INS WITH GRANITE COUNTERTOPS. THE REMODELED KITCHEN SHOWCASES QUARTZ COUNTERTOPS, A LARGE CENTER ISLAND, CLASSIC SUBWAY TILE BACKSPLASH, STAINLESS STEEL APPLIANCES, CERAMIC TILE FLOORING, AND ABUNDANT CABINETRY. THE CUSTOM MUDROOM WITH BUILT-IN CABINETRY ADDS STYLE AND FUNCTIONALITY. THE FINISHED LOWER LEVEL FEATURES A SPACIOUS REC ROOM, WET BAR, MEDIA AREA, AND FULL BATH. THE FIFTH BEDROOM IS CURRENTLY CONFIGURED AS A HOME THEATER WITH A PROJECTOR AND SCREEN BUT CAN ALSO SERVE AS A BONUS ROOM, GUEST SUITE, PLAYROOM, OR HOBBY ROOM. THE LUXURIOUS PRIMARY SUITE FEATURES A RENOVATED SPA-INSPIRED BATH AND CUSTOM-DESIGNED WALK-IN CLOSET. THE HALL BATH AND POWDER ROOM HAVE ALSO BEEN BEAUTIFULLY REMODELED. ENJOY YOUR PRIVATE BACKYARD RETREAT WITH A NEW PAVER PATIO, PROFESSIONAL LANDSCAPING, IRRIGATION SYSTEM, AND NO REAR NEIGHBORS. THE OVERSIZED TWO-CAR GARAGE WITH A TANDEM THIRD BAY OFFERS EXTRA SPACE FOR A WORKSHOP, GOLF CART, OR STORAGE. ADDITIONAL UPDATES INCLUDE A NEW ROOF (2020), HVAC (2021), WATER HEATER (2022), NEW CARPET (2023). IDEALLY LOCATED NEAR PARKS, WALKING TRAILS, SHOPPING, DINING, MAJOR FREEWAYS AND AIRPORT. A WONDERFUL PLACE TO CALL HOME!

6319 Lake Mathias Drive, New Albany

Listing Courtesy of : DeLena Ciamacco ---- RE/MAX Connection

$2,250,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ Erin Spalding

A front-row seat to one of New Albany Country Club's most picturesque settings. Set on a premier nearly .8-acre cul-de-sac corner lot overlooking the pond and park, this exceptional home pairs timeless architecture with the views, privacy, and lifestyle that define NACC living. The home blends architectural character with modern functionality, creating spaces equally suited for entertaining and everyday living. It offers expansive, light-filled spaces and a seamless connection to the outdoors. The chef's kitchen features professional-grade appliances, custom cabinetry, an oversized island, and opens to the great room, dining room, and sun-filled morning room. Filled with natural light, the home offers both pond and park views and a private backdrop of mature landscaping and expansive green space. A dedicated study and four-season room provide inviting spaces to work, relax, and unwind. The spacious owner's suite serves as a private retreat, featuring an oversized walk-in closet and generously sized bath with room to personalize and elevate. Secondary bedrooms offer recently updated ensuite baths, while the finished lower level provides additional living and entertaining space complete with an egress window and full bath. Outside, a recently added stone patio, mature landscaping, and an expansive yard create a private retreat with ample room for recreation, gatherings, or a future pool. A rare combination of exceptional setting, thoughtful updates, and timeless design in the heart of New Albany Country Club.

7593 Fenway Road, New Albany

Listing Courtesy of : Erin Spalding ---- Cutler Real Estate

$1,695,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ Shawn Redman

Nestled along a highly desirable picturesque tree-lined street leading to a private cul-de-sac within the New Albany Country Club community, this exceptional five-bedroom residence blends timeless elegance with modern luxury. From the moment you enter, the beautifully appointed foyer sets the tone for the sophisticated interiors that follow. A handsome private office with custom built-in cabinetry overlooks the manicured grounds, creating an inspiring work-from-home setting. Wide-plank oak flooring flows throughout the main living spaces, leading to an inviting L-shaped great room that connects to the screened porch and outdoor entertaining areas. Step onto the brick patio, complete with a fireplace and fully equipped outdoor kitchen, designed for effortless entertaining and year-round enjoyment. The recently renovated gourmet kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring premium appliances, custom cabinetry, an inviting breakfast area, and a spacious pantry. Entertain with ease in the formal dining room, complemented by a convenient butler's pantry. The expansive four-room primary suite serves as a private retreat, offering a sun-filled morning deck, generous living space, and a stunning spa-inspired bath designed for relaxation. A sophisticated dressing room, workout space and second laundry room complete the experience Two additional bedrooms each with their own en-suite baths, while a separate bedroom suite is thoughtfully positioned away from the main sleeping quarters, providing ideal privacy for guests or multi-generational living. The finished lower level is equally impressive, offering a spacious family room, fireplace, wet bar, and a fifth bedroom suite, making it the perfect destination for entertaining or extended stays. Numerous recent improvements enhance both comfort and peace of mind. Beautifully designed, meticulously maintained, and thoughtfully updated, this is a rare opportunity to own one of the New Albany Country Club's most exceptional homes.

7752 Sutton Place, New Albany

Listing Courtesy of : Shawn Redman ---- Street Sotheby's International

$1,800,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ Peter J Gardikes

Rare New Albany Country Club East Course estate blending privacy, luxury, and meticulous upgrades on a near-acre premium site. A well landscaped half-circle turnaround driveway creates striking curb appeal, while a second private security gated driveway leads to the heated 3 car garage. The park-like rear yard offers ultimate rear yard seclusion with mature trees and professional landscaping. The front open yard has entertained large tented events. Outdoor living thrives on multiple sealed brick and new paver patios, complete with a stone walkways, metal fencing, gas grill, dry creek bed for drainage, and expanded irrigation system. Inside, the home features marble entry to the open foyer, high-end ceramic tile throughout the first level, and elegant crystal chandeliers. The gourmet kitchen boasts premium stainless appliances, dual gas ovens, and custom island lighting. Unwind by the fireplaces featuring an Amish Live Oak mantle in family room. All exterior doors are upgraded to stunning Mahogany. Owner's suite is a luxury retreat with fireplace and bathroom that features granite countertops, track lighting, a whirlpool tub, and a custom shower with seating. The remodeled hall bath serves the main level. The Carriage Suite above the garage features two private bedrooms, new tile floors, a remodeled bath, and dedicated AC. Original owner commissioned painting above the Carriage Suite loft wet bar features a view of the golf course and country club house from the house when it was originally built. Entertainment awaits in the finished cellar walkout basement, showcasing professionally stained cement floors, large rec room with fireplace, decorative ceiling tiles, full bath off the den, and a custom bar with a wine chiller and mini-fridge. Mechanical excellence ensures peace of mind with a Generac whole-house generator/transfer switch, new upper AC, and new mechanicals. View Upgrades and Updates as well as Floor Plan in Documents.

4184 Baughman Grant, New Albany

Listing Courtesy of : Peter J Gardikes ---- Duros Realty Company

$1,180,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ Gail Tobias

Set on a picturesque tree-lined street in the heart of highly desirable Planters Grove neighborhood, this stunning home perfectly blends timeless neighborhood charm with classic elegance. Surrounded by mature trees and natural landscaping, this property offers a private oasis of peace and beauty. A gently flowing stream winds through the grounds, passing beneath a charming footbridge, creating a serene backdrop and a connection to nature for everyday living. Step inside to a light filled, open floor plan that creates a warm, inviting atmosphere ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. The bright kitchen features SS appliances, a large center island, ample counter space and a casual dining area. It flows seamlessly into a comfortable sitting room with panoramic windows that bring in abundant natural light and showcase the scenic surroundings. The great room showcases a gas fireplace, warm hardwood floors, and custom built-in cabinetry, while a formal dining room adds a touch of traditional elegance. A private office with custom built-in shelving and cabinetry provides a functional and refined workspace. The main level primary suite serves as a relaxing retreat, complete with tray ceiling, and walk-in closet. The ensuite bath features heated floors, dual vanities, a freestanding tub, and a spacious walk in shower. Upstairs, two generously sized bedrooms each include their own private full bath, ensuring comfort and privacy. With direct access to the outdoors, the bright walkout lower level extends the home's exceptional livability. A spacious gathering area with a wet bar and fireplace is ideal for entertaining or relaxing, while two additional bedrooms and a shared full bath provide privacy and comfort for family or guests. Step outside to a brick patio with a firepit, perfect for enjoying the outdoors. Located just moments from leisure trails, parks, green space, and nearby amenities.

4056 James River Road, New Albany

Listing Courtesy of : Gail Tobias ---- New Albany Realty, LTD

$999,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ Ramamohan R Sanepalli

Luxury Living at Its Finest | 5 Bedrooms | 4.5 Bathrooms | 5,446 Sq. Ft. | New Albany-Plain Local Schools Welcome to this beautifully updated luxury home offering 5 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, and 5,446 square feet of exceptional living space in the highly sought-after New Albany-Plain Local School District. Thoughtfully designed for both entertaining and everyday living, this residence is filled with premium upgrades and modern conveniences. Sophisticated front elevation accent lighting, fresh interior and exterior paint, and beautiful wood flooring throughout create an impressive first impression. Touch-sensitive light switches add a contemporary touch throughout the home. The gourmet kitchen features granite countertops, abundant workspace, and exceptional functionality, complemented by a second dishwasher in the basement kitchen and matching granite finishes in the wet bar and lower-level entertaining areas. Entertainment options abound with a dedicated home theater featuring a negotiable short-throw laser projector, a dance floor with LED lighting, a mirrored home gym, and a whole-home multi-zone audio system serving the main level, primary suite, basement, and outdoor spaces. The fully finished lower level includes an additional bedroom with an egress window, providing flexibility for guests or multigenerational living. A granite-surround fireplace and four-season sunroom offer inviting spaces to relax year-round. Outdoor living is equally impressive with a spacious deck, patio, and gazebo perfect for entertaining. Additional upgrades include a sprinkler irrigation system, Kinetico reverse osmosis water system, sump pump with battery backup, and a newer roof with a lifetime warranty. This exceptional home combines luxury, comfort, and functionality in one of Central Ohio's most desirable communities, offering a rare opportunity to enjoy sophisticated living in a premier location.

8411 Galdino Drive, New Albany

Listing Courtesy of : Ramamohan R Sanepalli ---- RE/MAX Town Center

$1,045,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Thomas A McKee

Welcome home to this spectacular 5-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom home featuring 4,027 square feet of living space designed perfectly for modern living and entertaining. Step inside the large living room featuring soaring vaulted ceilings, a cozy gas fireplace, and tons of natural light through a wall of windows. Just off the living room is the heart of the home: a chef-style kitchen with a large island that provides the perfect cooking space, plenty of cabinets, and a large pantry. Just off the kitchen is a versatile bonus area ideal for a breakfast nook, secondary office, or a chic coffee bar that walks out directly to a beautiful, covered deck--perfect for your morning coffee or evening relaxation. Also off the kitchen is a large dining room perfect for entertaining or holidays. Nearby, a dedicated large office offers the ultimate remote-work setup. Uniquely designed with two primary bedroom suites, this layout offers unmatched flexibility. The main-floor primary suite features its own private gas fireplace for ultimate comfort. Upstairs, find the remaining bedrooms, including the second spacious primary suite. Practical amenities include a massive 3-car garage and a vast, unfinished walkout basement bursting with potential for a gym, theater, or recreation room. Do not miss your chance to own this New Albany gem in the Gahanna school district

2905 Highland Woods Boulevard, New Albany

Listing Courtesy of : Thomas A McKee ---- Coldwell Banker Realty

$1,595,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ Alan D Hinson

Nestled on a quiet cul-de-sac in the highly desirable Pembrooke neighborhood, this beautifully maintained residence offers 4,749 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space. Featuring four bedrooms and four-and-a-half baths, the home showcases an open-concept floor plan ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. The heart of the home is the spacious center-island kitchen, seamlessly connected to the inviting family room and sun-filled morning room. Additional main-level highlights include a formal dining room and a private study. The finished lower level provides exceptional flexibility with generous space for recreation, fitness, or media enjoyment. Outdoor living is equally impressive, with a brick terrace overlooking a large fenced rear yard. Completing the property is an attached three-car garage and a premier location just moments from New Albany's renowned amenities, parks, schools, and country club lifestyle. Owner is a licensed Real Estate agent in Ohio New Furnace and AC Unit 2021 New roof and gutters - 2021 New driveway - 2025 Brick side walks replaced - 2024 Brick Patio 2021 In ground dog fence surrounding house, including front yard Basement vinyl flooring installed fall 2025 New hardwoods installed 1st and 2nd floor in 2023

3762 Pembrooke Green E, New Albany

Listing Courtesy of : Alan D Hinson ---- New Albany Realty, LTD

$2,300,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ Mark B Neff

Modern elegance best describes this amazing New Albany Country Club Community, builders own personal home. 2 years young. Loaded with amenities. 7621 Total SQ ft across 3 floors. Beautiful 2 story entry foyer with lots of natural light, flanked by a private office. First floor is an amazing chefs kitchen 133' island which seats 7 plus adjacent full dining area, full messy kitchen/walk in pantry w/professional appliance package throughout. Fantastic great room with fireplace + extra cabinets/beverage center. Second first floor flex office. Incredible master suite, luxury spa bath + two walk in closets w/ stackable laundry. Second floor has 3BR 3BA plus full laundry and fully finished bonus room with beautiful wood beams, this provides for extra flex/guest/recreation space and option for another office area. Finished lower level has 5th BR/BA, bar/kitchenette, awesome wine cellar, large recreation/media area and full work out room. Gorgeous back yard with covered porch, dining and sitting area with fireplace and full outdoor grilling center, with built in grill and big green egg, refrigerator and backs to amazing privacy trees. This is right around the corner from the Oxford park and connected leisure trails to Planters Grove, Planters Grove park, Oakland Nursery and The New Albany Country. Club. Just two miles to Market Square and 1/4 mile to Rogers Corners retail area featuring The Barn restaurant, HighBanks Distillery and Donatos Pizza. 1.5 miles west is the Hamilton Quarter district with all your shopping needs and 4 miles to Easton, 10-15 minute drive to Columbus International Airport.

7100 Oxford Loop N, New Albany

Listing Courtesy of : Mark B Neff ---- New Albany Realty, LTD

$1,295,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ Stacy Tackett

Not all luxury homes are created equal, and at 4025 Chelsea Green W, the difference is in the details. Built in 2013 by M/I Homes and meticulously upgraded, this Georgian showcase in Lansdowne at New Albany Country Club offers something rare: the craftsmanship of a custom home with the systems, finishes, and bones of a newer build. Inside 4,389 sq ft of beautifully curated living space, every room has been thoughtfully elevated. The main floor Owner's Suite features a fully redesigned spa bath with a custom-tiled walk-in shower and brushed nickel hardware. The chef's kitchen showcases Yoder custom black walnut cabinetry, a granite island, pro-grade range, and a brand-new LG craft ice refrigerator. Dark hardwood floors flow throughout, freshly refinished stairs (April 2026), and custom touches abound, designer fireplace mantle with floating bookshelves, a home office with built-in pull-out file system, LED lighting, plantation shutters, and crown molding in every room. Upstairs, three generous bedrooms plus a spectacular private Bonus Suite, its own bedroom and full bath, ideal for guests, multigenerational living, or a premium retreat. A dedicated home gym/hobby room rounds out the lower level, which is fully plumbed and ready for you to finish exactly as you envision: home theater, wine cellar, guest suite, your call, your design, no structural work required. The 3-car rear carriageway garage keeps the street view pristine, pure curb appeal, no garage doors. Three HOAs cover lawn, mulching, and snow removal for true lock-and-leave living, steps from golf, tennis, five pools, and fine dining at NACC. Newer. Upgraded. Ready. Schedule your private showing today.

4025 Chelsea Green W, New Albany

Listing Courtesy of : Stacy Tackett ---- Keller Williams Consultants

$4,250,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ Robert J Riddle

Overlooking the West 9 of the New Albany Country Club golf course, this brand-new custom residence offers approximately 6,600 sq ft of thoughtfully designed living space and a 4-car garage. Exceptional attention to detail and quality construction is evident throughout. A two-story foyer with custom millwork creates a welcoming introduction and opens to a light-filled main level. A private office with glass doors is ideally positioned near the entry, offering a quiet workspace. White oak flooring runs throughout, complemented by clean white walls, detailed trim work, and a cohesive, understated finish palette. The kitchen features two expansive islands with generous prep space, seating, and storage. Custom cabinetry, high-end appliances, and seamless integration with the main living areas create an open yet intentional layout. Adjacent living and dining spaces are well-defined, offering flexibility while maintaining a natural flow. The home includes five bedrooms and six bathrooms, highlighted by a first-floor primary suite offering a private, well-appointed retreat with a spacious bath and walk-in closet. Additional spaces include a dedicated exercise room and a secondary family or club room, suitable for recreation, media, or guest accommodations. The finished lower-level features egress windows that bring natural light along with a wine cellar that adds character and usability to the space. Outdoor living is thoughtfully designed as an extension of the interior, with a pool and spa oriented to capture open golf course views while preserving privacy. A covered second-floor balcony provides an additional outdoor retreat. Additional highlights include a four-car garage equipped with an EV charger and a layout designed with long-term livability in mind. For added convenience, this home is available fully furnished, creating a seamless move-in ready opportunity.

4105 Highgrove Crescent, New Albany

Listing Courtesy of : Robert J Riddle ---- New Albany Realty, LTD

Browse All New Albany OH 5 Bedroom Properties for Sale

5 Bedroom New Albany Real Estate